When I was a kid I encountered this problem when I wondered what would happen if I half-empty a bottle of soda, re-fill it with water, and repeat. Will it eventually become just water or will there always be some soda left? It boggled my mind for a while, then I forgot about it until I reached university calculus haha
You mean less steps. True homeopathy dilutes until there’s no measurable amount of the substance left; it’s just pure sugar/water/alcohol. You’re supposedly getting benefits from “the vibrations.”
Of all the pseudo-science quackery, homeopathy is one of the most idiot-prone.
No, I do mean more steps, because homeopathy dilutes a smaller volume of target material, they actually would perform fewer steps than dilution via halving.
Homeopathy often dilutes by taking far less than half of a solution and diluting it in a large amount of fresh solvent. One process repeatability empties the entire container and refills it with solvent.
If you were diluting something by replacing only half with solvent, you’d have to do many more steps to get as pure solvent as homeopathy produces.
Homeopathy is a tremendously wasteful way of washing a container. It’s hugely wasteful, and being a homeopathic environmentalist is oxymoronic.
The answer is that eventually all trace of the soda would be gone because there are only a finite number of atoms of “soda-stuff” and eventually you’ll end up with a situation where there’s only one molecule left, which - assuming that wasn’t the water part of soda in the first place - will have a 50% chance of being in the half that’s removed before the next dilution step. Theoretically it could survive infinitely many rounds of this, but the chance of that is basically zero.
How many times is that though? For a litre of soda, the lower bound is about 85. A hundred ought to be more than enough. (And 300 times would be enough to dilute the entire observable universe assuming it was soluble in water, so that’s a reasonable upper bound.)
You’d almost certainly stop tasting the soda quite a while before that though. After 20 dilutions you’re into parts per million soda to water.
Things become more complicated if you replace the soda in this experiment with holy water. It seems to be agreed that 50/50 holy to regular water remains holy, but after that, some believe that dilution can be repeated forever (presumably being left to sit for a while after that step) while others claim the holiness disappears once the dilution goes beyond 51%, regardless.
When I was a kid I encountered this problem when I wondered what would happen if I half-empty a bottle of soda, re-fill it with water, and repeat. Will it eventually become just water or will there always be some soda left? It boggled my mind for a while, then I forgot about it until I reached university calculus haha
You invented homeopathy! Just with more steps (literally).
You mean less steps. True homeopathy dilutes until there’s no measurable amount of the substance left; it’s just pure sugar/water/alcohol. You’re supposedly getting benefits from “the vibrations.”
Of all the pseudo-science quackery, homeopathy is one of the most idiot-prone.
No, I do mean more steps, because homeopathy dilutes a smaller volume of target material, they actually would perform fewer steps than dilution via halving.
Homeopathy often dilutes by taking far less than half of a solution and diluting it in a large amount of fresh solvent. One process repeatability empties the entire container and refills it with solvent.
If you were diluting something by replacing only half with solvent, you’d have to do many more steps to get as pure solvent as homeopathy produces.
Homeopathy is a tremendously wasteful way of washing a container. It’s hugely wasteful, and being a homeopathic environmentalist is oxymoronic.
That’s exactly what I mean.
The soda dilution by halves would have far more dilution steps to reach pure water than homeopathy.
Ah. I read you backwards, by bad.
All good, language is freakin hard, man!
All that matters is we got there in the end :)
I get benefits from sugar water alcohol.
What about the shaking? If you don’t aCTiVate it, it won’t work.
Hmm good call, infinite soda hack!
A little too accurate?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HMGIbOGu8q0
The answer is that eventually all trace of the soda would be gone because there are only a finite number of atoms of “soda-stuff” and eventually you’ll end up with a situation where there’s only one molecule left, which - assuming that wasn’t the water part of soda in the first place - will have a 50% chance of being in the half that’s removed before the next dilution step. Theoretically it could survive infinitely many rounds of this, but the chance of that is basically zero.
How many times is that though? For a litre of soda, the lower bound is about 85. A hundred ought to be more than enough. (And 300 times would be enough to dilute the entire observable universe assuming it was soluble in water, so that’s a reasonable upper bound.)
You’d almost certainly stop tasting the soda quite a while before that though. After 20 dilutions you’re into parts per million soda to water.
Things become more complicated if you replace the soda in this experiment with holy water. It seems to be agreed that 50/50 holy to regular water remains holy, but after that, some believe that dilution can be repeated forever (presumably being left to sit for a while after that step) while others claim the holiness disappears once the dilution goes beyond 51%, regardless.
It’s easy to test for water holiness. If you drop the bottle and it bursts into flame molotov-cocktail style, it is still holy water.
Source : Belmont et al., Wallachia, 1986
“If something can happen, it will happen.”