So I have it set to disabled within the user, and as an overall setting, but they still show as default. I’m not sure why

Edit: looked through the settings again and realised I didn’t have them set to “none” they were set to “default”. Switched that setting and all working correctly now.

Thanks for helping me solve a year long problem!

Interestingly I don’t have a problem with how subtitles look, but the fact they are always on by default is my biggest headache!