• 0 Posts
  • 66 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: July 4th, 2023

help-circle



















  • That’s not entirely honest - you’re also trying to argue that having this option is not a good or valid option (you called “debatable”) and are trying to steer the conversation by creating a false equivalency between assistance in dying and suicide, which are not the same thing.

    I fully agree with your example - someone unaliving themselves on a deserted island committed suicide. Never said they didn’t.

    What I said, and what you’re conveniently omitting, is that suicide is an act by an individual, there is no other party to the unaliving. This is not the case in assistance in dying, and there’s very good legal reason why we consider these distinct from eachother, and from murder (to your earlier point).

    Even if we forget the traumatic angle I brought up earlier, surely you must see the difference between an act that involves one party and an act that involves two parties with express intent and consent.

    What you’re trying to do is the same as arguing masturbation and sex are the same thing because they end with the same result (orgasm).