Just in the last few months, it seems like everyone who is doing content creation on youtube (etc.) is holding a tiny mic up, in the frame of the camera.
I get that mics are needed, but a good desk mic or a headset or whatever else you might imagine is just as good acoustically, and far less distracting. And they were all in use up until a few months ago.
Is this just a fashion trend?
YT and TT are platforms that breed weird quirk uniformity. They all grab your attention with the same phrases (“you’ll never believe …”, “what about [insert something outrageous]? Let me explain …” etc.) For a while, everybody had the same Ikea shelves behind them crammed with shit. Then I think we moved on to neon signs. It used to be fashionable to show off your expensive big microphone, probably much to the delight of its manufacturer. And that’s why I wouldn’t be surprised to learn that the manufacturer paid some influencers to hold the tiny mike prominently in the shot like they would hold a dog poop bag filled with poop from a stranger’s dog. And then it was copied.
They often still have the expensive microphone, but use an unplugged tiny microphone just for the aesthetics.
I don’t know if this is true but the absurdity is hilarious to me so I’m choosing to believe you.
I have seen a few you tubers jokingly show that it was disconnected. Because yes, at some point even that became a meme. But I couldn’t find an example off the top of my head.
So make a new business of selling empty tiny mics… No wires, no circuits… But 20% cheaper
It may work out…
The fad has passed. Now the trend is using random objects as microphones.
There was a time that this was something we made fun of. Now this is the goal
Is that Al ? (This “l” is an “L”, as in AL)
No it’s Garth, though his last name starts with Al.
I have to imagine this is the case for a decent chunk of people with those tiny mics, right? Sometimes the audio quality of the talker sounds way better than I would expect from essentially a lapel microphone, and there’s just a regular microphone out of frame.
Not going to lie the tiny mics are a pet peeve of mine like many others in this thread, but I can’t explain it well as to why haha.
I’m a big fan of not an engineer, who just uses random objects
not the only person I’ve seen do it, but the first that comes to mind
I think you’re on to something here. I have had noticed that in some channels I’ve watched where it seems like their room is way too perfect? Probably not the right word, but it’s off-setting to see how their environment is orchestrated. Like it’s the in-thing to do, so that is their way, a way of conformity. Then when that in-thing is no longer that thing, out with that environment into something else that’s trendy.
I would hate myself a lot if I was making videos and had to orbit my life around what a manufacturer, marketer, advertiser .etc wants to see me project.
Keeping a single corner of a room tidy isn’t that hard, and these are professionals, frequently making some very good money to keep that corner of a room neat and tidy. it isn’t any more of an accident, seeing something in the camera frame, than, say, all the times you see an MS laptop and it’s logo, or an apple laptop with that logo. or all the coke bottles and cans in movies and tv shows.
If you see a logo, it’s because someone paid them to show it.
I don’t mind the Kallax or Ivar shelves with stuff. It’s a cheap way to show what your videos are about.
But they are completely nondescript tho, unless they actually name the brand you’ll have to know the mic from sight alone. Which is easy when it’s a shure SM58 or SM7B, but when it’s a tiny lavalier mic scotch taped to a hammer that’s pretty difficult.
From what I gather it is to look more authentic and in the moment, unprepared.
I’m amazed at how many people found rogan authentic. Is it the same sort of podcasters playing off people’s intuitions, like the fact checker used to?
Which is really bizarre in a studio setting.
deleted by creator
Nebula mirror: https://nebula.tv/videos/tomnicholas-why-youtubers-hold-microphones-now
I wanted to link to this video myself but you beat me to it
I was similarly intending to do so, but was also beaten
That was a great watch, but I think it’s actually more simple than that. Content creators want to focus on their content. If it is now considered acceptable to have a mic on camera, hiding it is one less thing they have to deal with while shooting.
I do find it extremely odd to hold a lav mic though. Maybe that’s the only mic they own. I donno.
That was a pretty wild ride! Despite an hour of in-depth discussion, it really seems to come down to an affectation.
They’re ads for microphones. Any brand logo you can see clearly in-frame I assume is a paid product placement. Your favorite folksy, down to earth content creator just “keeping it real” has to make a living. And sponsorships and advertising is how it has been done since the start. Your favorite personality, at the end of the day, is an actor working for corporations.
I’m sitting here with my Pepsi and I completely agree. The one point you made is perfect much like the one calorie in Pepsi one. How can “one” be so much? Because it’s the one you depend on when flavor counts! You and Pepsi know this and help us all find the refreshment or carefully planed ideas.
The choice is clear and it’s sugar free!
It’s like people only do things because they get paid… And that’s really sad.
Winner winner chicken dinner.
Yeah I was totally going for that scenes vibe!
IDK why but it it annoys the hell out of me, especially given that those kind of mics are meant to be worn on your shirt.
If you’re going to make a career out of media, you should at least know how to use your equipment properly. It’s unprofessional and almost as annoying as starting your video out with “hey guys”.
Take a 101 course on A/V and radio communications at your local community college before you begin broadcasting is all I’m saying. Put in the bare minimum effort before you try to go attracting millions of viewers.
I think a good chunk of them know exactly how to correctly use the equipment and are doing it on purpose for aesthetic.
You don’t have to watch
I don’t. But they pop up in my girlfriend’s feed all the time so I’m exposed to it regardless.
I like the gimmick of clipping them onto random objects and using that as a mic tbh
I recently saw a YouTuber wearing a yellow smiley T-shirt use the mic as the nose.
I find it obnoxious and distracting.
I thought it was kinda funny when some random YouTuber did it 5 years ago. Now i just think: still haven’t figured out a new gimmick to vopy, huh?
haven’t figured out a new gimmick to vopy, huh?
Is that what you call it when vloggers copy things?
What do you call it when cloggers copy things?
Cloppy
You kill me
You too
Then dont watch lol
I watch clips where people can be heard super-clearly on lowly clip-on mics.
There is no reason to hold it in your hand. You’re not Bob Barker.
Compare with the vapid influencerati trash holding their phones like pizza slices and shouting into them and turning the sound uploke they’re on some reality trash show. Telling them that they’re absolutely using it wrongly, that engineers have tuned the mic and speakers for a completely different orientation, is just lost. So I make fun of them.
The YouTube microphone situation is crazy…
The original tiny-mic legend, Nat’s What I Reckon reviewing the overpriced-boatshow.
He grabs anything kicking around, for a mic-holder. (Find the one where he uses a sprig of rosemary as the mic-holder)
OK, before asking this question, I was merely baffled. Now after this video, I hate holding tiny mics, hate tiktok and youtube content creators, and hate everything about the internet more than ever before.
No clue. Not really a social person. I can say that for every day there will likely be a new trend starting and an old one dying.
My content rarely has me showing up in it and even then microphones tend to not work very well at 60 feet under water. Then again that gives me an idea, I can take a fake fish under water with an attached fake mic and do a voice over later on for some fun…
It’s funny that’s why
Here is a good video explaining the trend: https://youtube.com/watch?v=0arvnAlV_C4
